top of page
Search

Electronic Toys: Do the Benefits Outweigh the Drawbacks for Child Development?


The use of electronic toys and digital media by young children has sparked much debate. Proponents argue interactive technology promotes learning and development, while critics warn it may be detrimental. Research into the impact of electronics on child development has shown mixed results. Some studies reveal benefits, others suggest potential harms, and many note it likely depends on factors like the type of technology, extent of use, content quality, and whether it displaces more traditional toys and parent-child play time.


In this article we review key areas where electronics may influence developmental outcomes in early childhood. Potential benefits explored include cognitive skill building, motor development, social interaction, language and literacy, attention training, and more. Risks discussed involve issues like technology addiction, exposure to inappropriate content, reduced physical activity, and disrupted sleep. The latest evidence is presented to help parents make informed choices about integrating tech into their young child's life.



Cognitive Benefits

Electronic toys can provide cognitive benefits for children when used in moderation.

  • Electronic toys can help develop problem solving skills. Many games require strategy, critical thinking, and logic to advance to new levels and complete tasks. This promotes cognitive development.

  • Following instructions and sequences in games promotes learning. As children progress through levels, they must apply what they've learned and continue building on existing knowledge.

  • Educational electronic toys are designed specifically to teach concepts like math, reading, science, and more. Interactive platforms allow for hands-on learning.

  • Electronic toys that respond to children's actions help reinforce cause-and-effect relationships. Children can see how their behaviours directly impact outcomes.

  • Creative play is encouraged by open-ended games without strict rules. This allows children to set their own goals and think imaginatively.

The key is balance. Electronic toys can have cognitive benefits when used appropriately, but an overreliance on electronics can be detrimental. Setting limits and monitoring play is important.

Motor Skill Development


  • Games that require physical movement and coordination can improve gross motor skills like balance, coordination, and spatial awareness. Playing with remote control cars or other toys that children move around themselves engages their large muscles.

  • Touch screens and games that require precise finger and hand movements help develop fine motor skills and hand-eye coordination. Tracing letters and shapes on a tablet teaches control and dexterity.

  • Some electronic toys like dancing robots or bikes with video screens are designed to encourage physical activity while playing. Anything that gets kids up and moving helps strengthen muscles and motor development.

  • Building games and robotics kits that snap together pieces encourage fine motor skills. Assembling the parts takes concentrated effort.


Social Interaction


Electronic toys often lack socialization that comes with traditional play. But educational games can promote cooperation and joint problem-solving. Multiplayer games encourage interaction with peers.

Some key points:

  • Electronic toys are often single-player, limiting social skills learned through play.

  • Traditional toys like blocks, dolls, and board games provide opportunities for shared imaginative play.

  • However, many good electronic games actively promote working together, taking turns, and verbal communication.

  • Educational multiplayer games can teach teamwork, collaboration, and social skills.

  • Games played together in person provide more social benefits than online games.

  • Moderation is key - excessive solitary gaming displaces time spent interacting with others.

  • Parents should encourage both electronic and traditional playtime with siblings and friends.


Language and Literacy


  • Reading instructions and following storylines in toys promotes literacy. Some electronic toys are designed to teach reading skills.

  • Some electronic toys directly aim to teach reading, writing, and language abilities. Games and apps can help kids practice alphabet recognition, phonics, vocabulary, etc.

  • However, passive screen time is unlikely to help language development as much as interactive play. Simply watching videos does not provide opportunities for conversation, reading body language, or practicing communication skills. Hands-on play encourages more practice with literacy fundamentals.





Attention and Focus


  • Fast-paced, overstimulating games have been linked to shorter attention spans in children. The constant flood of stimuli can make it difficult for kids to focus on less exciting tasks like homework or reading.

  • However, well-designed educational games often require concentration, patience, and sitting still for extended periods. The interactivity keeps children engaged to complete multi-step challenges. This can help strengthen their focus and attention skills. Moderation is important to prevent dependence on constant stimulation from electronics. A balance of both digital and hands-on play is ideal. Monitoring screen time and ensuring offline activities can allow children to develop their ability to pay attention without relying solely on technology for engagement.


Addiction and Behavior


  • One common concern is that children can become addicted to video games and electronics. It's important to monitor screen time and set reasonable limits to prevent compulsive behavior.

  • Some research indicates a link between exposure to violent video game content and increased aggression in children. However, more studies are needed to establish causation.

  • Parental supervision is critical. Checking game and app ratings, knowing what your child is playing, and discussing any concerning content can help mitigate risks.

  • Setting screen time limits, designating electronics-free areas like bedrooms, and requiring outdoor or social time are effective ways to balance technology use.

  • Look for signs of attachment to devices like tantrums when limits are set. Some addiction-like behavior may indicate an underlying issue to address.


Physical Activity


Excessive screen time is linked to sedentary behavior and obesity in children. Many kids today are spending several hours per day staring at a screen instead of engaging in physical play and exercise. While active video games like those played on Wii or Kinect provide some physical activity, research indicates they do not provide the same benefits as unstructured outdoor play and free movement.

However, some electronic toys are designed to encourage physical activity and movement. Ride-on toys, control toys, dancing or musical games, and outdoor exploration tools can get kids running, jumping, dancing, and engaged with their environment. Electronic toys focused on movement and exploration tend to provide more benefits than those centered solely around screens. Moderation is key, and a balance of screen time and physically active play is ideal for health and development.


Sleep


  • Screen time before bed can disrupt healthy sleep patterns in children. The blue light emitted from electronic devices suppresses melatonin production, making it harder for children to fall and stay asleep.

  • Melatonin is the hormone that regulates sleep-wake cycles. Blue light exposure in the evening tricks the brain into thinking it's still daytime, delaying the release of melatonin and disrupting the body's natural circadian rhythms.

  • It's important for children to have a screen-free time before bed. This allows their bodies to start preparing for sleep by producing melatonin. Having consistent pre-bedtime routines and limiting electronic device use can help improve sleep quality and duration.

  • Inadequate or disrupted sleep can negatively impact children's mood, behavior, cognitive abilities, and physical health. Ensuring healthy sleep hygiene practices early on is crucial for proper growth and development.


Conclusion


The use of electronic toys and devices can provide both benefits and downsides for children's development. Here is a summary of some of the key points:

  • Electronic toys and devices can help develop cognitive skills like problem-solving, spatial skills, and hand-eye coordination in moderation. Too much usage may be detrimental.

  • Apps and games can help develop fine motor skills and visual tracking. However, reliance on touchscreens may delay fine motor development.

  • Social skills may be hindered by excessive solitary play with electronics. Face-to-face interaction remains crucial for language and social development.

  • Educational apps can aid literacy and learning. But passive screen time should be balanced with creative play, reading and social interaction.

  • Some electronic toys help train focus and attention. However, excessive stimulation can decrease attention span.

  • Behavioural addiction is a risk with excessive or unsupervised electronics use. Setting limits is important.

  • Replacing physical activity with too much sedentary screen time can be unhealthy long-term. Outdoor play is still essential.

  • The bright lights of devices can disrupt healthy sleep when used before bedtime. Limiting evening screen time is recommended.


In conclusion, electronic toys and devices do offer developmental benefits for children in moderation. But an excess of solitary, passive screen time can be detrimental. A balanced approach, with reasonable time limits, supervision and engagement from parents, is recommended. The key is moderation - electronic toys can be educational and fun, but should not replace traditional play, social interaction, outdoor activity and other essential developmental experiences.



References:

Nechtem, C. The Impact of Technology on Children. 2021. Available online: https://www.cerritos.edu/hr/_includes/docs/August_2021_The_Impact_of_Technology_on_Children_ua.pdf Radesky, J.S.; Peacock-Chambers, E.; Zuckerman, B.; Silverstein, M. Use of mobile technology to calm upset children: Associations with social-emotional development. Levine, L.E.; Waite, B.M.; Bowman, L.L.; Kachinsky, K. Mobile media use by infants and toddlers. Comput. Hum. Behav. E Kipling Webster, Fundamental motor skills, screen-time, and physical activity in preschoolers De. Cara Goodwin, 2023, Are Electronic Toys "Bad" for Children's Development?

Comentários


bottom of page